Another chance for our voices to be raised!! Sign the petition against the transition tax!!!
Part 2: The Transition Tax: Is “Resistance Futile”? The Possible use of the Canada U.S. Tax Treaty to Defeat the “Transition Tax”
cross-posted from citizenshipsolutions blog
Beginning with the conclusion (for those who don’t want to read the post) …
For the reasons given in this post, I believe that there are grounds to argue that the imposition of the Sec. 965 “transition tax” on Canadian resident/citizens DOES violate the Canada U.S. tax treaty. It is my hope that this post will generate some badly needed discussion on this issue.
If you are an individual who believes you may be impacted by the “transition tax”, you should consider raising this issue with the Competent Authority. I would be happy to explore this with you.
Need some background on the Sec. 965 “U.S. transition tax”?
The following tweet references a 7 part video series about the Internal Revenue Code Sec. 965 “Transition Tax” created by John Richardson and Dr. Karen Alpert.
Understanding the @USTransitionTax – the possible implications for small for small business owners who do NOT reside in the United States – A 7 part video series with John Richardson and Dr. Karen Alpert https://t.co/MfsK7ArrcL
— John Richardson – Counsellor for US persons abroad (@ExpatriationLaw) February 13, 2018
(Video 6 gives examples of what various approaches to “Transition Tax Compliance” might look like.)
FATCA, the Compliance Mafia, The Swamp & the Deep State in the League of Non- Aligned Nations
How does a country move from nobly declaring FATCA to be a breech of sovereignty — to signing a FATCA document with the Obama regime over the course of just a year? Well, the compliance-mafia / Deep State has either a Mustafa or a Slobo on call for whatever the Deep State needs in whatever country needed.
Perhaps you remember the days when we prayed for some FATCA IGA fightback? Country after country fell to the Nobel Peace Prize winner’s extra-territorial FATCA citizen-spy tool. First, the big 5 fell. Then Norway got the Deep-State John Doe payoff, and shortly afterward the entire world caved to FATCA IGAs. Finally, the never-tiring JustMe threw in the resistance towel and disappeared into mountain bliss.
Then, while a few of the expected put up some symbolic resistance and disinterest, a tiny bit of valiant resistance popped up. A tiny country publicized a resistance. This is a country known for resistance–A country who had lost 1/5 of its population fighting off its occupiers in the first world war (the Ottomans and the Austro-Hungarians), A country who had resisted the Nazi occupation, with both its communists and royalists, whilst fighting its own civil war between themselves, whilst rescuing 500 forgotten Americans expatriated behind enemy lines. It was also known as joining together others as non-aligned nations in resistance of both the east and the west.
Unfortunately this country known for its resistance, also takes pride in having lost its wars and sovereignty on a regular basis over the centuries. Beginning with things such as having its entire army defeated by the Ottomans while sleeping off a hangover, living centuries as slaves to the Ottoman occupiers, delivered to communists by spies as loot for the defeat of the Nazis, and finally destroyed by a Deep State / Jihadi alliance. All of this, while still resisting invaders with spirit. And then, the Stepford Wives got well appreciated by them, when the witch Madeleine Albright got herself stoned in the area she had “liberated”.
So, as another day in history, Aug 11 of 2014, the valiant Serbs put up resistance to America, and announce that real Serbians would be protected from the wrath of the long arm of the IRS and its FATCA. But actually, it was visible a year prior that non-submission would not be tolerated, that the Compliance Mafia deep state would be imported by an invading American McKinsey-firm accounting lackey to rule the Serbian Financial Sector as minister of Serbian finance.
Serbia has a history of resisting occupiers, like the 4-century occupying Turkish jihadists who maintained the right to break in and take pleasure of any house, business, or marriage . But there were small bits of resistance, such as the famous businessman Pirot Hrista Jovanavic, who built his office with a low ceiling so as the tall Turkish invaders would have to bow when they broke into his office.
However, Prime Minister Vucic is actually a master at announcing resistance to the Deep State, to foreign powers, and to the influence of foreign cultures. He typically makes such announcements of resistance to parties such as the Arabic nations, all-the-while selling off the most valuable downtown property to oil-rich barrons. He is known for feigning resistance to the EU, Turkey, Hungary, and US, all the while awarding sweet deals to foreigners for his country’s previously state-owned properties.
Unfortunately again this time FATCA resistance was not to be, as the currently-reigning vassal Prime Minister Vucic arranged for the McKinsey mafia to arrive and do the work of the Obama Deep State, one year prior to the announcement of resistance. In just a short year, the Deep State Mole landed in Serbia and implemented the Obama Ottoman-invasion extra-territorial FATCA edict. He left, just days after signing the FATCA surrender and months prior (12 Jul 2014) to the country, its media, and Brock Society even realizing (11 Aug of 2014) what had happened.
Prime Minister Vucic feigned resistance, which we had cheered, but Vucic resistance was actually well after the fact. Oh well, Vucic has often feigned similar resistance—afterall, he had hired a humanitarian progressive American-plant, neocon wet dream—a lesbian Croatian (Deep State) USAid graduate to be Prime Minister.
There is no better display of Deep State Compliance Mafia FATCA implementation than at the Obama / Deep-State vassal Vucic implementation of FATCA with Serbia’s temporary employment of an American McKinsey accountant to a place as finance minister. As a result, US citizens residing in Serbia will remain under the control of Obama-dominated FATCA / FISA / FINCEN Deep-State surveillance. Any returned war refugee or NGO baby will forever be a slave to the Obama FATCA Ottoman tax regime.
Dear Candidate Trump, would you like to rescind the Obama Executive IGA orders for FATCA and eliminate layers of expensive FATCA regulations?
Some of us look forward to the potential for Trump leadership to eliminate Obama regulations and intrusions upon American citizen–but no one is holding their breath. How about you Make It Great for American Citizens Again and eliminate FATCA and FBAR and eliminate Citizenship-Based-extraterritorial taxation? A few Executive orders of your own could undo 8 years of Obama Ottoman-like tyranny and allow 9 million U.S. expat Americans to live in peace and freedom…and to once again look back to their home country. Dear Candidate Trump—what say you #MakeItGreatforAmericansAgain?
Part 1: Responding to The Section 965 “Transition Tax”: “Resistance is Futile” but “Compliance is Impossible”
Cross-posted from the citizenshipsolutions blog
Part 1: Responding to The Section 965 “transition tax”: “Resistance is futile” but “Compliance is impossible” https://t.co/HMUi0Nw1rU
— John Richardson – lawyer for "U.S. persons" abroad (@ExpatriationLaw) March 2, 2018
Introduction and background …
“This legislation is being interpreted by a number of tax professionals to mean that individual U.S. citizens living outside the United States are required to simply “fork over” a percentage of the value of their small business corporations to the IRS. Although technically “CFCs” these companies are certainly NOT foreign to the people who use them to run businesses that are local to their country of residence. Furthermore, the “culture” of Canadian Controlled Private Corporations is that they are actually used as “private pension plans”. So, an unintended consequence of the Tax Cuts Jobs Act would be that individuals living in Canada are somehow required to collapse their pension plans and turn the proceeds over to the U.S. government” -John Richardson
Canadians’ Confidential Tax Info to be Shared with Police in Other Countries
Well, to the rest of the Canadian people, “Welcome to Our World!” In the same manner as the Harper Government, the Trudeau Liberals are using budget bills to sneak in provisions the Canadian people are completely unaware of. I sincerely hope we see Canadians rise up and challenge this garbage. Now we can add “tax evasion” to “terrorism” as the means by which governments are destroying any rights ALL citizens have.
by Elizabeth Thompson
Senior Reporter, CBC Ottawa
elizabeth.thompson@cbc.ca
Article is here
(1100 Comments -Commenting is now closed for this story)
EXCERPTS
Confidential information from Canadian taxpayers could soon be shared with police and authorities in three dozen countries around the world, under measures included in Finance Minister Bill Morneau’s latest budget.
In an inconspicuous section tucked into a small 78-page annex to the budget, the government says it wants to give police and tax authorities new powers to fight tax evasion and advance international investigations into serious crimes, ranging from drug trafficking and money laundering to terrorism.
***“If you can get something buried in the budget that nobody knows about, sometimes you can get something passed without getting the kind of heat it deserves,” said Michael Bryant, executive director of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and a former Ontario attorney general.
“Well, this deserves a lot of heat from the opposition and scrutiny from media.”
Michael Bryant, Executive Director CCLA, former Attorney General for Ontario
***Currently, the Canada Revenue Agency can share confidential tax information about Canadians with authorities in other countries that are investigating serious cases, such as tax evasion. However, under Canadian law, the CRA cannot share that information with officials in another country investigating a crime other than tax evasion.
***The proposed new policy affects more than tax information.
***While tax authorities in other countries can ask Canada for an individual’s tax information, that policy currently doesn’t extend to other information like bank account records. Under a second proposal, the government would allow the legal tools contained in the Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters Act — such as court orders — to be used to obtain information being sought by another tax authority.
***While the proposal was included in the budget, it will require the approval of Parliament before it can become law and be implemented. Finance Department spokesman Jack Aubry said it has not yet been decided whether the policy will be part of the budget implementation bill or some other piece of legislation.
Comment #2 on “Think You Can Leave the U.S. – Think Again
“There is something fundamentally wrong with a country where compliance with its laws
forces you to (eventually) renounce your citizenship.”
This post is based on a comment by John Richardson. The comment is a response to
a post by laurainparis on the Thom Hartmann blogsite.
*******
Laura, you conclude your last comment with:
“In asking his question Thom demonstrates the importance of how the United States treates it citizens when they leave the country. He demonstrates that this is an important question not just for Americans who live outside the US, but for ALL Americans, regardless of where they live. Because anyone who thinks they can leave the country, anyone who comforts themselves with this idea – anyone who asks the question “why don’t more Americans leave?” – they are deluding themselves. There is no freedom for Americans. Americans are not free to live normal lives outside the US, unless they are financially and emotionally prepared to STOP BEING AMERICANS (that is, renounce their citizenship). The word “ironic” doesn’t begin to describe the situation. The words “impossible” and “tragic” do.”
A tragic situation indeed.
What’s most interesting and tragic is that:
The ones who try the hardest to comply with the U.S. rules are the ones who ultimately are forced to renounce. I have assisted a very large number of people in renouncing their U.S. citizenship (and thereby ending U.S. jursidction over them). A high percentage of people I have assisted are people who:
1. Have tried for years to comply with the “alphabet soup” series of laws and reguations that govern the lives of Americans abroad; and
2. Realize that compliance is no longer possible.
The only remaining Americans abroad will be “noncompliant” Americans abroad
In the long run, the only Americans abroad who will be able to retain their U.S. citizenship are those who do NOT attempt compliance with these laws. There is something fundamentally wrong with a country where compliance with its laws forces you to (eventually) renounce your citizenship. This is a problem that has escalated over time.
Continue reading
What is Tax Residency? – Episode 2 with John Richardson & Olivier Wagner
“Tax residence American style” AKA : Imposing “worldwide taxation” on those with @taxresidency in other countries
The issue of tax residence has gained so much attention since the “crackdown” on non-resident US Persons began in 2009. It is commonly understood that you pay taxes to the country/state/city-town that you reside in. (For an interesting comparison of differences between countries please see this incredible list compiled by the OECD). It simply does not occur to anyone that they would be required to pay taxes to a foreign government.
However, the United States claims jurisdiction due to citizenship. One does not even have to have touched foot in the U.S., according to U.S. law. Of course, due to the viciousness of the U.S. “FBAR Fundraiser” many people began to resist whether of anger or fear.
Not much has changed* , in spite of all the factors that have contributed to this debacle (and debacle it is, what could one expect when a country tries to take what is someone else’s, based on an idea of fake residence?).
For a detailed discussion concerning the determination of tax residence and related factors, please see here.
In a #FATCA and #CRS world: There's "residence", "#taxresidence" and "@taxresidency American style (where you reside in the USA even if you don't) – @1040Abroad and @Expatriationlaw: ‘Episode 2: "A Tax Residency Primer"- Tax, Residency and #TaxResidency": https://t.co/n2xjvHDhqy
— John Richardson – Counsellor for US persons abroad (@ExpatriationLaw) August 8, 2018
In this interview, John Richardson speaks with Olivier Wagner about tax residency and how a seemingly simple concept has become so terribly important in the 21st century.
At the 38 minute mark, we talk about how to describe U.S. “tax residence”.
Comment on “Think You Can Leave U.S. – Think Again”
My comment on the superb article about the plight of #Americansabroad by @Laurasn1000 https://t.co/OPflDEmehD … Calling the other Laura – @Saunderswsj
— John Richardson – lawyer for "U.S. persons" abroad (@ExpatriationLaw) February 18, 2018

Recently an excellent article Think you can leave the US? Think again!
appeared on the Thom Hartmann site.
Written by an expat laurainparis , it is one of the best summaries/sources of information available. This post is based on a comment to the article.
*******
Laura, this is one of the very best articles I have seen about the reality of this situation.
At the outset, I would like to explain that what most people call U.S. “citizenship-based taxation” (sounds kind of patriotic) is the U.S. policy of “imposing worldwide taxtion on the “tax residents” of other countries who do NOT live in the United States” (which is what it really is). In other words, let’s call it like it really is. It is NOT restricted to “so called Americans abroad”. The vast majority of people impacted by this are the citizen/residents of other countries.
You explain what it means when the United States claims the right to impose “worldwide taxation” on the residents of other countries. This of course means (as you know first hand) that a resident of France must pay U.S. tax on his/her French income. In addition (as you point out) the penalty regime imposed on assets that are local to the resident of France but “foreign” to the USA are draconian and completely idiotic.
I would also like to point out that although this discussion is frequently framed in terms of “taxation”, what this is really about is the United States exporting the Internal Revenue Code to other countries. This exports certain U.S. cultural values, reporting requirements and penalties on those who “commit personal finance outside the United States”. In other words, this is about much more than taxation.
Continue reading
One More Time! TTFI Petition Seeks Signatures
JC posts:
VERY IMPORTANT! You want a change, sign the petitions. You do not want a change, do nothing.
TTFI PETITION.
What is Tax Residency? – Episode 1 with John Richardson & Olivier Wagner

The issue of tax residence has gained so much attention since the “crackdown” on non-resident US Persons began in 2009. It is commonly understood that you pay taxes to the country/state/city-town that you reside in. (For an interesting comparison of differences between countries please see this incredible list compiled by the OECD). It simply does not occur to anyone that they would be required to pay taxes to a foreign government.
However, the United States claims jurisdiction due to citizenship. One does not even have to have touched foot in the U.S., according to U.S. law. Of course, due to the viciousness of the U.S. “FBAR Fundraiser” many people began to resist whether of anger or fear.
Not much has changed* , in spite of all the factors that have contributed to this debacle (and debacle it is, what could one expect when a country tries to take what is someone else’s, based on an idea of fake residence?).
For a detailed discussion concerning the determination of tax residence and related factors, please see here.
In this interview, John Richardson speaks with Olivier Wagner about tax residency and how a seemingly simple concept has become so terribly important in the 21st century.
In a #FATCA and #CRS world – the most interesting thing about a person is where has @taxresidency ESPECIALLY when he has > one. @Expatriationlaw interview with CPA @1040Abroad: ‘Episode 1 of: "A Tax Residency Primer"- Tax, Residency and #TaxResidency" https://t.co/6swfQmJO7i
— John Richardson – Counsellor for US persons abroad (@ExpatriationLaw) August 8, 2018
- *DOS says 9 million US citizens live abroad
- *from 2009-2016, 100,000 taxpayers came into compliance via OVDP and Streamlined
- * in 2011 449,277 Forms 2555 (FEIE) were filed; see breakdown by country;
- * in 2011 3,921,628 Forms 1116 (FTC) were filed; see breakdown by country
- *in 2015, 1,163,229 FBARs were filed
- The numbers above strongly suggest that a large majority of non-resident Americans are not tax compliant



