Introduction
Last week I posted the news that “some” former U.S. citizens (renunciants) had been denied ESTA authorizations to visit the United States.
This morning, I became aware of this article reporting new requirements on train operators entering the United States. The article by Ethan Cotler confirmed that:
U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) has proposed a rule that could deny cross-border rail passengers boarding before the train even leaves the station. In addition, CBP says it’s drafting a plan to expand its authority over cross-border bus carriers.
The proposal comes roughly a month after an Appeals Court panel ruled that CBP officers at ports of entry and airports can search travelers’ phones without a warrant, probable cause, or reasonable suspicion. Amtrak’s Cascades, Adirondack, and its jointly-operated Maple Leaf all provide service between the U.S. and Canada, meaning Canadian passengers on train services that cross into the United States would be subject to the pending rule.
A huge “shout out” to Mr. Cotler for a well researched article, which focussed on the requirement from the perspective of entering the United States.
The actual text in the Federal Register includes:
U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) is proposing to require rail carriers to transmit advance electronic traveler information to CBP for any individual (crew and passengers) who is arriving in or departing from the United States on board a train. The rail carrier also would be required to transmit an advance notice of arrival or departure, as applicable, for the train. This rule would enhance security while facilitating legitimate international travel on board trains.
Interestingly (and perhaps more significantly) the proposed rule would impact BOTH individuals entering the United States AND individuals leaving the United States.
Even more interestingly, the proposed rule derives its authority from the 1930 Tariffs Act. Think of it: legislation enacted almost 100 years ago to control the movement of goods being used almost 100 years later to control the movement of U.S. citizens?
The bottom line is:
The United States is proposing to require train operators (Amtrack and any other train company entering the United States or departing from the United States on a route that will leave the United States) to transmit advance information about each passenger to U.S. customs. Generally, the information would be similar to the information on your passport. Put another way – it sounds like the information submitted when one applies for an electronic travel authorization.
The proposed requirement appears to be slated to take effect from December 14, 2026 (jut in time for the holiday travel season.)
The purpose of this post is to four-fold:
- To call attention to the proposed rule and what it appears to mean
- How the proposed rule impacts those entering the United States
- How the proposed rule impacts those leaving the United States
- How to register comments if you are so inclined
In addition, short Appendix will provide the statutory authorization for the proposed regulation.
Part 1 – The proposed rule and what it appears to mean
C. Summary of the Proposed Rule
This rule would require rail carriers to transmit an advance notice of arrival or departure, as applicable, for any train that is arriving in or departing from the United States with a traveler on board, including a train that crosses the U.S. border while in transit. The notice of arrival and notice of departure would be due no later than 24 hours prior to the train’s arrival at the U.S. border crossing location on the inbound and outbound trips, respectively.
Additionally, the rule would require rail carriers to transmit advance electronic traveler information to CBP for any individual (including crew and passengers) who will arrive in or depart from the United States on board the train or who crosses the U.S. border while in transit. The required information would include information generally found on a passport or other DHS-approved travel document, including name, date of birth, sex, country of citizenship, country of residence, and DHS-approved travel document type, number, country of issuance and expiration date, if applicable. The information would also include other identifying information such as status on board the train ( i.e., conductor, engineer, passenger, crew); complete itinerary of the traveler; address while in the United States for all travelers, except those in transit; alien registration number, if applicable; traveler’s passenger name record locator, if available; known traveler number, if applicable; redress number, if applicable; baggage tag information, if applicable; and seat location, including car and seat number, if available. The required information would also include contact phone number with country code and email address, if available.
After the rail carrier transmits the required information, CBP would conduct an initial vetting of the advance information and send a response message to the carrier. The response message would state either that CBP accepted the transmission or that the rail carrier must contact CBP prior to departure. If CBP’s vetting of the traveler information does not identify any traveler of concern, then the response message will state that CBP has accepted the transmission. In such a case, no further advance action by the rail carrier is required. However, if CBP has identified a traveler of concern, then the response message will indicate that the carrier should call CBP and will provide a phone number for the carrier to call. Upon contacting CBP, the carrier and CBP will attempt to resolve any concerns regarding the traveler, such as by confirming whether there are any errors in the transmitted information. If CBP’s vetting flags a traveler as having potential security, immigration, customs, or other law enforcement issues, then CBP may recommend that the carrier not board the traveler.
Carriers would have two options for transmitting the required advance electronic information to CBP. Under the first option, rail carriers would transmit the advance electronic information through a CBP-certified transmission system. Under this option, a carrier would be required to submit its electronic transmission system to CBP for testing and CBP would have to certify that the rail carrier’s system is capable of communicating with the CBP system for effective transmissions of data and receipt of appropriate messages. Under the second option, rail carriers could transmit the advance electronic information through any CBP-approved electronic data interchange system, such as the Electronic Advance Passenger Information System (eAPIS) web portal,[4] or any CBP-approved application with manifest capabilities.
Here is a pdf of the complete notice.
Part 2 – How the proposed rule impacts those entering the United States
At a bare minimum, the effect of this regulation will be to make travel to the United States even more unpleasant than it already is.
That said, the United States of America has the right to:
A. Create “Fortress America”; and
B. Defend “Fortress America” by controlling who enters and who leaves.
Part 3 – How the proposed rule impacts those leaving the United States
Although the focus of the Facebook post was on flagging passengers entering the United States, what I found more interesting was that the requirement would apply to those leaving the United States. Of course, (as is well known to all U.S. citizens outside the USA, but unknown to U.S. citizens inside the USA), a U.S. citizen – as per INA 1185 – is NOT permitted to leave the United States without a U.S. passport. Of course, the issuance of a U.S. passport is purely discretionary. (What this really means is that no U.S. citizen has no right to leave the United States, but who really cares about that?) As Ron Paul suggested on September 7, 2011 (in the context of building a wall along the U.S. southern border) , sooner or later things designed to keep people out will be used to keep people in!
I think that this is incredibly significant and is consistent with Ron Paul’s 2011 prophecy! I wonder if Homeland Americans will understand the significance of this! The regulation is aimed at any individual leaving the United States!
Part 4 – How to leave comments if you are so inclined
You can see comments that have been submitted here.
Comments must be received by December 14, 2026.
Please submit comments, identified by docket number, by the following method:
- Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov. Follow the instructions for submitting comments via docket number USCBP-2026-0992.
Instructions: All submissions received must include the agency name and docket number for this rulemaking. All comments received will be posted without change to http://www.regulations.gov, including any personal information provided. For detailed instructions on submitting comments and additional information on the rulemaking process, see the “Public Participation” heading of the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of this document.
Docket: For access to the docket to read background documents, a plain language summary of the rule, or comments received, go to http://www.regulations.gov.
Appendix – The law that authorizes this proposed regulation
A. Legal Authority
These proposed regulations are authorized by sections 431 and 433 of the Tariff Act of 1930, as amended (Tariff Act) (19 U.S.C. 1431, 1433).[6] Specifically, section 433(d) of the Tariff Act requires the person in charge of a vehicle (which includes trains) to transmit to the Secretary of Homeland Security (Secretary), pursuant to an electronic data interchange system, such information, data, documents, papers, or manifests that the Secretary may require by regulation.[7] 19 U.S.C. 1433(d). Section 431(b) of the Tariff Act requires that the master, person in charge of a vehicle, or an authorized agent of the owner or operator of a vehicle, to sign, produce, deliver, or electronically transmit any manifest required by the Secretary in accordance with the regulations. 19 U.S.C. 1431(b).
Section 431(d) of the Tariff Act requires the Secretary to promulgate regulations that specify the form for and the information and data that must be contained in a manifest and prescribe the manner of production for, and the delivery for electronic transmittal of, a manifest. 19 U.S.C. 1431(d). Additionally, a train arriving in the United States may only depart from the port or place of arrival in accordance with regulations prescribed by the Secretary, unless otherwise authorized by law. Tariff Act sec. 433(e) (19 U.S.C. 1433(e)).
These statutory provisions grant the Secretary the authority to issue regulations that require a person in charge of a train to electronically transmit data, documents, papers, or manifests and to specify in the regulations what information and data must be transmitted. The Secretary has delegated its statutory authority relating to these requirements to the Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP). See DHS, Delegation No. 07010.3, Delegation of Authority to the Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection II.A (Rev. No. 03.2, Incorporating Change 2) (Dec. 11, 2024).
JR Commentary: It appears that this legislation is broad enough to require the driver of a private vehicle to transmit passenger information prior to arriving at the U.S. border. Could it really go this far?
JR Commentary: Notably the authority for this is the 1930 Tariff Act. Would the creators of this legislation have imagined that it could be used almost 100 years later to control the movement of people both leaving and entering the United States?
For 20-plus years, I’ve been an occasional traveller on the Adirondack (Mtl/NYC) train, and have travelled the route while a dual citizen and now, as solely Canadian. The process for clearing customs on that train is boarding in Montréal (no customs inspection) and then the train stops in rural upstate New York (Rouses Point) where US customs officers board and proceed with the inspection. (Canadian customs coms on board on NYC/Mtl leg at Lacolle QC). If even one person is flagged for supplementary inspection, the entire train waits, and in my case that’s added 1.5 hours or longer. That person is taken to the canteen car, which is closed for the duration of the inspection, so passengers cannot get any food or water and even going to the toilet is a production.
Customs inspection in the station of departure is far more efficient. Also, if the person entering US is denied, they must disembark in Rouses Point with no public transit and extremely limited options for alternative transportation to Canada.