The contemporary model of civil forfeiture in the US was introduced as part of the “war on drugs”. Under terms of this law, which varies across US jurisdictions, law enforcement officers can seize property involved in unlawful, or suspected unlawful activity, such as drug dealing. In some jurisdictions, law enforcement organisations are allowed to keep some or all of the assets seized. This has led to some notable abuse, notoriously in Tenaha, Texas, but in other jurisdictions too.
Why post this to IBS? Just an interesting aside on the “culture” of confiscation in the US.
“In general, you needn’t be found guilty to have your assets claimed by law enforcement; in some states, suspicion on a par with “probable cause” is sufficient. Nor must you be charged with a crime, or even be accused of one. Unlike criminal forfeiture, which requires that a person be convicted of an offense before his or her property is confiscated, civil forfeiture amounts to a lawsuit filed directly against a possession, regardless of its owner’s guilt or innocence.
“One result is the rise of improbable case names such as United States v. One Pearl Necklace and United States v. Approximately 64,695 Pounds of Shark Fins. (Jennifer Boatright and Ron Henderson’s forfeiture was slugged State of Texas v. $6,037. [their story earlier in the article – Northernshrike]) “The protections our Constitution usually affords are out the window,” Louis Rulli, a clinical law professor at the University of Pennsylvania and a leading forfeiture expert, observes. A piece of property does not share the rights of a person. There’s no right to an attorney and, in most states, no presumption of innocence. Owners who wish to contest often find that the cost of hiring a lawyer far exceeds the value of their seized goods. Washington, D.C., charges up to twenty-five hundred dollars simply for the right to challenge a police seizure in court, which can take months or even years to resolve.”
“…But civil-forfeiture statutes continued to proliferate, and at the state and local level controls have often been lax. Many states, facing fiscal crises, have expanded the reach of their forfeiture statutes, and made it easier for law enforcement to use the revenue however they see fit. In some Texas counties, nearly forty per cent of police budgets comes from forfeiture.”
The typical victims are poor, often black or Hispanic, i.e. individuals without the means to contest what’s been done to them.
Just saw this item today:
“A US woman accused of using her espresso stands as drive-through brothels is suing the city of Everett in Washington State to recover $250,000 she says was wrongfully seized by police.
“Carmela Panico owns the Java Juggs and Twin Peaks ‘bikini baristas’.
“She was arrested and accused of promoting prostitution, but has not been charged. (Emphasis mine)
“The cash was seized in a search of her home.
“The lawsuit was filled after Ms Panico was notified that the city planned to keep the cash as proceeds from criminal activity.”
Well, good luck getting your money back, Carmela….
Herald Sun Aug 8 2013 (no remarks, it’s in the lunch room 🙂 )
Here is the video for the Obama youth group.
Personally, Obama has inspired me to relinquish my United States citizenship.
@Northernstar: Please read the following disclaimer that has been posted here for over a year on the right hand side of the front page: “Also, the Isaac Brock Society does not necessarily endorse videos or other material which are posted here for informational purposes.” The video has been posted for informational purposes.
In deference to USCAbroad and because he asked, I have removed the embed to video. Those who wish to understand what this discussion is about my still consult it at Youtube. I am doing this in my function as administrator/editor (as a request to edit a comment) not as a comments editor or moderator (that job belongs to Pacifica).
Another great example of confiscation starting here:
Pingback: The Isaac Brock Society | Civil Forfeiture: The new #OVDP confiscation program for those in U.S. borders
Pingback: The two kinds of cash deposits that can lead to account seizures in the USA | U.S. Persons Abroad – Members of a Unique Tax, Form and Penalty Club