The specific problem in the U.S. tax reform bills related to U.S. person-owned incorporated businesses in Canada, Australia, France, UK, etc. appears to have been identified.
However, apart from the general solution of changing the bills’language to end U.S.-imposed worldwide taxation on individuals, WHAT IS THE ONE SENTENCE CHANGE IN WORDING OF THE TAX BILLS LANGUAGE THAT WOULD FIX THE PROBLEM IDENTIFIED IN THIS POST?
This one sentence change could be sent to the drafters and supporters-antisupporters of the bills.
IF YOU ARE INTERESTED, YOU CAN FORWARD OUR PRESS RELEASE WITH YOUR COMMENTS TO POLITICIANS AND OTHER ORGANIZATIONS IN U.S., CANADA, AND ELSEWHERE.
Tricia has some thoughts that you might include (in a comment below).
— In this press release we ask United States Congress to fix a problem in the present House/Senate tax bills that targets certain Canadian citizen/residents who own an incorporated business — and more broadly — to “stop imposing worldwide taxation on any Canadian resident”.
The press release is being sent in part to members of U.S. Congress and also to Canadian politicians who should be in the business of defending Canadian citizens from harm caused by a foreign state.
The focus of the press release is intentionally on “Canadians”. The word “American” is not mentioned. Our use in the text of the now-offensive term “U.S. person” (defined by the U.S. Internal Revenue Service) does not imply that U.S. person law applies to any Canadian resident or that any of these so-designated (by the U.S.) Canadians have ever consented to be U.S. persons.
Here is the link to the press release.
November 24, 2017
For Immediate Release
U.S. CONGRESS: DO NOT CONFISCATE OUR SMALL CANADIAN BUSINESSES AS PART OF YOUR TAX REFORM
On November 16, 2017 Rep George Holding, of the House Ways and Means Committee, in an exchange with Chairman Brady, urged that as part of tax reform that: The United States join the rest of the world by adopting “residence-based taxation”. This would END the U.S. current practice of imposing worldwide taxation on certain residents of other countries.
As U.S. law currently stands, many Canadian citizen/residents (who are deemed by the U.S. to be “U.S. Persons”) find themselves subject to U.S. taxation (ON THEIR CANADIAN INCOMES and CANADIAN ASSETS), even though they live in Canada and pay taxes to Canada.
The application of U.S. tax law into Canada – a principle enforced by FATCA – has profoundly negative consequences, some of which are intended and some of which are unintended.
This is a request that the wording of the United States “Tax Cuts and Job” bill be revised so as not to harm, even more, small Canadian businesses possibly included, we believe inadvertently, by your proposed tax reform legislation.
As your tax Senate and House tax reform bills are presently worded, Sec. 14103, for example in the Senate bill, might be interpreted to confiscate a significant percentage of the retained earnings of certain small “Canadian Controlled Private Corporations”. This is evidently part of broader legislation to implement “territorial taxation”, in order to enhance the competitiveness of publicly traded U.S. multinational corporations.
We believe that this section is intended to apply ONLY to the foreign subsidiaries of U.S. domestic corporations. However, a strict reading of the language of the bill suggests that this “transition tax” MIGHT also be paid by those who are deemed by your country to be “U.S. persons” living overseas who happen (as is common in Canada) to own an incorporated small business. The “minnows” swept up by your bill will then include small businesses such as a one-person incorporated medical doctor’s clinic, should the owner be designated by U.S. law to be a “U.S. person”.
We do not believe that this was your intention and ask that you fix the language of the bills accordingly. Surely you would agree that “territorial taxation” for U.S. multinational corporations does NOT mean that the United States should extend its taxable “territory” to Canadians who happen to own small Canadian Controlled Private Corporations!
As part of U.S. tax reform, we conclude by asking that the United States stop imposing worldwide taxation on any Canadian resident AND clarify that the “Tax Cuts and Jobs” Bill does NOT apply to Canadian residents who are shareholders of Canadian Controlled Private Corporations.
On behalf of the
Alliance for the Defence of Canadian Sovereignty (www.adcs-adsc.ca) Information@adcs-adsc.ca;
Alliance for the Defeat of Citizenship Taxation (www.citizenshiptaxation.ca)
Contact Mr. John Richardson at firstname.lastname@example.org
Alliance for the Defence of Canadian Sovereignty/Alliance for the Defeat of Citizenship Taxation 283 College Street, P.O. Box 67678 Toronto, Ontario, CANADA M5T 3M1