cross-posted from MapleSandBox
also appeared yesterday on Rob Wood’s blog at Forbes
by Lynne Swanson
I am the author of this article in Forbes. I don’t know why Robert Wood didn’t use my real name as a signature. I submitted it to him and I have posted a comment asking him to include it. I refuse to hide or cower to a foreign bully.
Dear President Trump:
I realize that not paying taxes “makes (you) smart.” So you likely think I’m dumb for paying taxes to Canada, where I live. I think it makes me responsible. You probably would consider me “a nasty woman.” You might even call me a traitor because I have lived outside the United States for almost half a century, and relinquished American citizenship by becoming a citizen of the country I love—Canada—in 1973.
But hear me out on a real “total disaster.” The United States demands that I file tax returns to a country where I haven’t lived for 47 years just because I was born there. Even worse, the U.S. Treasury Department demands invasive information about all of my Canadian accounts. You see, Democrats, with support of some Republicans, passed the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) back in 2010. It is nasty, believe me.
I know you’re a really, really smart guy because of that not paying taxes thing. So let’s talk about FATCA, which is complex, believe me. Imagine if all of Melania’s accounts—including personal, business and even joint accounts with you—had to be reported to Slovenia just because she was born there! Or, if all of your accounts were required to be reported to Scotland because your mother hailed from there. Or, if the Czech Republic demanded all of the financial records of your three oldest children because of their mother’s birthplace. You get the idea.
This may sound like fake news, but is quite real for Americans abroad, including anyone born in U.S. These Americans are under attack, but not from terrorists. This FATCA attack comes from U.S. government! Terrible. You want to strip U.S. citizenship from anyone who burns an American flag? Ironically, if it was that easy to ditch U.S. citizenship, I’m afraid there would be Stars and Stripes ablaze around the globe. In fact, renouncing is costly, complicated and sometimes devastating.
Yet, renunciations of U.S. citizenship soared under President Obama’s administration. These people didn’t renounce because they are traitors or tax cheats. Many are patriotic Americans who built lives and paid taxes from Australia to Zimbabwe. But, IRS wants to claim them and seize their financial records because of their birthplace. Others are Accidental Americans because parents were temporarily living in the U.S. when they were born (like London’s Boris Johnson), or because a U.S. hospital was the closest one for their birth (like a Canadian police officer). I know of one Canadian caught in the FATCA nightmare whose mother went into premature labor over 50 years ago on an overnight trip to Buffalo!
Many financial institutions Build the Wall by refusing accounts to anyone born in America. Sadly, there are so many people now wanting to shed American citizenship that some U.S. Consulates have waiting lists of a year. Some are no longer responding to requests. Armed with alternative facts, sanctions and penalties, the U.S. Treasury and IRS have forced financial institutions and governments around the globe to comply with FATCA through bully-boy tactics. Your Russian Putin pal signed on, and so did China, Iraq and Mexico. But not Iran, Syria or Eritrea.
It’s strange about Eritrea, because it is the only other nation on the planet that taxes its citizens living outside its borders. But this tiny African dictatorship at least makes it easier than America does. Eritrea requests expat citizens pay 2% of their income using one simple form. No demand for financial records. No imposition of unwanted citizenship on everyone born there. In contrast, some tax compliance thugs threaten Americans outside the U.S. that the IRS will “Lock them up” if these mainly middle class folks don’t file tax returns. Notably, you haven’t released your tax returns, so I have no idea if you have offshore accounts or if you reported them.
You can straighten this out with an Executive Order for U.S. Treasury to stop tormenting millions of honest law-abiding folks who just want to live their lives in peace and protect their families and their privacy. You can urge Republicans in Congress to repeal FATCA and move to resident taxation as part of tax reform. Please ask your Chief of Staff to help. Mr. Priebus said FATCA is unconstitutional. The Republican National Committee even passed a resolution vowing to repeal FATCA and adopt residence based taxation. So dump FATCA, a “failing piece of garbage.” Please do it now. Make America Great Again, for all Americans.
A concerned former U.S. citizen”
I received an e-mail from Nigel Green’s Head of PR this afternoon. Mr. Green has asked if I will speak with him tomorrow evening.
I don’t know the focus yet, but it relates to his campaign. The request was motivated by my “fantastic letter” (his words) at Forbes.
So, here is someone who I hope will be very influential. He clearly does not think my letter was childish or spiteful. Mr. Green seems to value my views instead of telling me to “shut the fuck up.”
That is good news, congrats.
But inspired by today’s tweet from a Pennsylvania state senator, I think instead of “Dear President Trump” it should be addressed “Dear fascist, loofa-faced, shit-gibbon!”
That just made my afternoon. It’s better even than the all the post-Brexit Scottish abuse: “ferret-headed cockwomble” etc.
@nononymous: I was born and raised in Pennsylvania. Maybe it’s in good old PA genes!
@ Blazing Lynne
This is getting very interesting. You may or may not be able to tell us what transpires in your conversation with Nigel Green but either way it feels like steps are being taken in a forward direction. Surgite!
@EmBee I’m sure glad I asked Robert Wood to include my name and that he did it. I know he was trying to protect me but I won’t cower from a foreign government. Without my name being included with the article, I doubt that Mr. Green would have reached out to me.
“I was born and raised in Pennsylvania.”
Oh, the devil’s headquarters. No wonder you’re still ablaze after escaping from hell.
@EmBee, Others: I spoke with Nigel Green. We discussed him using the letter in the Repeal FATCA campaign.
Not good. This is very embarrassing and smells a lot like betrayal!
Somebody within the Trump cabinet certainly approved signing the recent FATCA IGA with Ukraine. Reince Preibus is all too aware of the RNC resolutions and campaign platform against FATCA and in support of RBT.
“Ukraine and the U.S. sign Intergovernmental Agreement to Implement FATCA”
@ Blazing Lynne
Thanks for the update. Your letter and their campaign are a good fit.
I wonder how youhavenoidea likes the taste of crow.