Just Me has written a lengthy response to the question, Has the IRS stolen your life? This is an important statement from the most famous minnow in the 2009 Overseas Voluntary Disclosure Program, about whom Amy Feldman wrote in her Reuters article. The IRS fined him $172,000 but the Tax Advocate Service managed to have it reduced to a non-wilful fine of $25,000. We are grateful for the contributions that Just Me has made to the Isaac Brock Society.
So, has my life been stolen from me? Hummm. Nah, not really, but a big chunk of time has been misappropriated, and it is up to me now to see what I can recoup from the IRS’s ill gotten gains.
Not to be a Polly Anna or an ornery contrarian here, but allow me a minute or two to focus on some positives, as every FBAR cloud has a silver lining, as they say.
I don’t think I need to repeat much of my experiences again here, as I have commented about them a lot at Jack Townsend’s blog, allowed Amy Feldman to publish some of it on the Reuters story, and have posted some of them here. I have also spoken to a few of you on the phone.
As you may know, I have often lamented the loss of LCUs (life credit units) that get devoted to all this unnecessary crap which is a total waste of human endeavor and time. I have felt the shock, the emotional trauma, loss of sleep and total waking hours obsession that many of you have felt, and really empathize with those feelings. I have felt the isolation of not being able to share what you are going through with family or friends mostly out of embarrassment, but also not wanting to be characterized as a tax cheat by those who know nothing of what the IRS has embarked upon and subjecting you to.
I have been equally outraged how immigrants to America are being treated, especially new ones, who arguably had an obligation to know the tax rules, but just benignly got caught out when the IRS decided to launch its education program via threats of criminal prosecution. For what? Failure to file an administrative form that very few professionals even paid attention to, the infamous FBAR.
Maybe my affinity for immigrants is because my wife is an Australian and a green card carrying US person, and just could not comprehend the absurdity of it all. It wasn’t logical to her. Australia didn’t treat her this way, but as I pointed out, with tax law, logic is the last thing you should expect. It is all about what they can do, not what they logically should do.
It is just shocking to me to see how brazen the IRS has been. Pulling that old piece of worthless paper off the “rarely used Statutes shelf”, and then applying it as a penalty hammer against all sinners in an equal punishment regime when they should have been narrowly focused on the USB type cheating Whales in the Homeland.
Who could have known that this was a ticking time bomb just waiting to go off? Well, actually, some professionals did, as I learned later. Hale Sheppard for one. He was the Nouriel Roubini of the FBAR melt down. Wished I had known about his writings back in 2005 when he was warning about the coming FBAR debacle we are now enduring.
I have posted his link before, but might just do it again. It is worth the read for those wondering how we got here.
Title: EVOLUTION OF THE FBAR: WHERE WE WERE, WHERE WE ARE, AND WHY IT MATTERS
The dilemma of the immigrants really pisses me off, as they say, and embarrasses me for how my country is treating them. After this episode, I think we should modify the Statue of Liberty inscription a bit about “your huddled masses yearning to breathe free” Perhaps France should reclaim it, as the IRS has shown the US to be unworthy of the gift anymore.
I have also been indignant at the mischaracterization by Commissioner Shulman about the great “success” he is having in bringing offshore tax cheats into compliance. and how much tax money he is recouping. I have been incredulous to learn that many Reporters work mostly as scribes. They just repeat IRS press release assertions without so much as one skeptical question. Like, what is the profile of those that were netted? What was the compliance improvement percentage that is being claimed? What was the Minnow to Whale ratio? What portion of funds collected was new tax, and what portion were penalties? The list is endless, if you have an inquiring mind. No one in the media has wanted to take it on, and it just befuddles me to no end.
So, I have had my share of anger and frustration, however, at the risk of sounding a bit sanctimonious, and as a coping mechanism, I have tried real hard to control my anger outwardly. IE, be measured in my responses with the IRS, and be sure I don’t take it out on those around me. Also,I try hard to keep my rants to a minimum for those whose antenna aren’t tuned for reception. Anger leads to hate, and hate harms you more than the object of your venom. Of course, you all know that, and yet it can’t help but eat away at you. Sometimes you do want to yell out, “I am as mad as hell, and I am not going to take it anymore.”
Then, you calm down, make a business decision and settle with the IRS hoping they will now just go away and leave you alone. Fatcat chance! 🙂
So, here I am 28 months after the discovery of my non compliance still writing about it, and sharing its impacts and lessons I have learned. I should let it go, and get my gardening done, but I guess I am captured by the passion of it all. Maybe I needed a cause in retirement, or maybe there is a bit of evangelical preacher in me that is coming out, or maybe I am an educator at heart, I don’t know. However, it has had a benefit for me, when I think about it. It has energized me in a way I haven’t felt for a while since the last big project I worked on before I retired. So there is a positive there, that I would not have considered prior to this.
So thanks for your post, as it has forced me to reflect and think about it a bit.
There is another positive. And, that comes from meeting folks like Roger Conklin, the 80 year old “rock-the-boat” star who energized me with his comments I had first seen at the WSJ and now his great contributions to this blog. I have come to appreciate the knowledge he has from the years he has been working on his passion to end US citizenship taxation. I have taken on board lessons from his example.
I have also had the pleasure of becoming acquainted with Jackie and Marylouise at ACA whose tireless efforts have given us all material and references to use in our education efforts for the US Homelander. Jackie was the one that directed me towards the TAS as a possible relief mechanism, when no attorney offered that advice. For that I am eternally grateful.
Then, there is all of you, many whose names I do not know, who came together in common purpose to “birth this blog” as an outlet for information sharing and expressions of comfort or hope. Is that not a BIG positive?
Another positive, believe it or not, was working with my examiner, Pauline, as drawn out and tedious as it was from long distance. She was always cheery, and willing to laugh at my jokes at her expense. She was a lovely gal, very polite and professional, doing her job as best she could, given the limitations put upon her. In a different setting, I think I could have enjoyed knowing her personally. She helped me realize that IRS agents are not all red-tailed devils inside the bureaucracy. In some ways, I felt she too was victimized by this process with the total lack of discretionary ability to do the right thing. If you are thinking that was a little Stockholm syndrome creeping in, I will give you that! 🙂
Another positive was getting to know about the TAS, an agency I didn’t know existed. I met some very fine folks there who really did advocate on my behalf, like Nina, Robin, Rosty, and Lucy to name a few. It was just amazing to find this best kept secret at the IRS! I could not ask for a more professional group to deal with who really went out of their way to be responsive to my plight. Every schedule and commitment they made, they kept. It restored my faith in one small US bureaucracy, and removed just a smidgen of cynicism I have about government in general.
I will always recall the comment from Rosty, the TAS attorney I was ranting to about what was wrong with the OVDP, and why I was not the willful cheat they were looking for. He cut me off mid stream and said, “You don’t get it. You needn’t convince me. We understand. We are on your side!” That realization was breath taking for me, as up to that moment it felt like I was fighting the entire IRS bureaucracy that was deaf and blind to the harm they were doing. And, I like to think, modestly, that maybe my experience had some impact on the TAD that Nina Olson’s office issued. Maybe not, but allow me the delusion, please. 🙂
Then there was this guy called Kevin McCarthy, who was (wait for this title) The Acting Director, Fraud/BSA Small Business/Self-Employed Division, Department of Treasury, IRS. Fit that onto a business card! He was assigned the task to reply to my first letter to Commission Shulman when I entered the OVDP. In that letter I was pleading for Minnow consideration and pointing out all the problems this was creating with as many logical arguments as I could muster. It didn’t matter, as it did not change a thing! However, ultimately it was his letter of reply, while unsatisfying at the time, did restate the terms of FAQ35. That turned out to be my ticket to a reasonably successful appeal via the TAS, long after FAQ35 had been rescinded.
When I was up against the wall with the VD process, I searched him out, called him, reminded him of his letter, and heard his audible human ‘sigh of recognition” when I pleaded my case. I pointed out that the penalties that arose from a program his department designed was resulting in totally disproportionate penalties for the “so called” crime. Was this want he wanted? How could this be right and just?
How did it measure up to the Geithner tax failure?
He too metamorphosized from a “devil from the dungeons of darkness” to a human with compassion for my plight. He arranged for a conference call with a Regional head of the OVDP, Gloria, that was totally outside the normal process and over the head of my examiner. This provided a forum for me to plead my case to an authority position. The TAS joined in that call, and I got a front row seat to one department of government grilling another in my defense. How sweet was that? The price for admission to that show was steep, but I recall it fondly. It was beneficial for me to see, and realize that there was some heart at the center of the beast.
Also, a very positive experience was my dealings with Jack Townsend, Phil Hodgen, and Hale Sheppard which restored my faith in attorneys as something better than ambulance chasing, blood sucking parasites, the unfair characterization we all like to joke about. They all did yeomen work, and their advice, both paid for, and complimentary was another positive aspect of this “adventure”. Jack’s and Phil’s blogs were especially helpful for great learning and excellent forums for commenting and sharing information.
Then there was the positive reward of having a well known author and The Atlantic blogger, James Fallows to actually spend some time reading my unsolicited emails, responding to me with advice, patiently acknowledging me on avalanche of follow ups, and actually comprehending what I was saying. That resulted in a 3 episode FATCA chronicles that stirred a lot of interest and discussion around the internet. The hash tag #FATCA lit up on Twitter, when he did his stories.
I have learned that even some minnow like me, who is willing to put in the time sending hundreds of emails, to various unknown reporters, with patience and persistence can eventually generate some attention. Will it change the world? No. However, it does give me comfort to know that it is still possible to influence a wider media discussion of issues important to me and others not seen. You just have to plug away at it. “Nothing ventured, nothing gained,” really rang true in practice. It was not just another soapy slogan on a self help poster!
Another positive of this, came during the “darkest of times” where I thought I was alone in a (not to be hyperbolic here) life and death financial struggle with the IRS, there were others experiencing my same fate. I began to realize that on this thing called an internet, there were some very active blogs dealing with these matters. There were many others going through the same agony as me. Maybe I wasn’t just a lone nutcase in the wilderness after all, crying out with my assertions that this entire VDP process was so wrong, and citizenship taxation, as I have learned, was at the core of the problem.
I have also learned that some out there in the vast “Ether” there are many too timid to post something on a blog or even ask a question. My activism and willingness to “tell my story” could work as a surrogate for their feelings and frustrations and help them out in their decision making. They do watch for your every word, perspective and comment, and you don’t know how many or who they are.
You too, dear reader, as much more sophisticated bloggers than me, are having a big impact on folks you will never meet. You may never get the thanks for it, but you should take comfort in your contribution and recognize the education and solace your commentary provides to others unseen or unspoken. With this comes a responsibility too, and that is to keep the forum as open, embracing and non partisan as you can. Don’t let it degenerate into a Left or Right ranting society. Just my opinion, and hope it is well taken.
I never fully realized these impacts, until the other day, when an Indian immigrant, who had been in America for 10 years, searched me out (I am not hard to find) and called me in New Zealand long distance from California. He wasn’t looking for advice on what to do, as he had already joined the OVDI, but he was looking for someone who could commiserate with him about the impact this was having on him and his family. He couldn’t express it to his friends. They didn’t understand. I knew exactly where he was coming from, and at that moment, I thought to myself, “Wow, my efforts are worth it to someone I never knew, and will never meet. How great is that? ”
In the end, this too will pass, one way or another, and some will leave this community of bloggers and new ones will join in. I may eventually fade away too, as time goes on. It will be interesting to see how it evolves.
Unfortunately, while America may extract from our backsides some relatively minor revenue to support the spending habits that an Empire requires, it will also lose much more. Citizens who have talent, energy and productive value will either renounce their Citizenship, grudgingly comply but join in the active negative marketing campaign around the world, or just go underground never to be seen again. That is a huge unintended cost to my birth nation from this ill conceived and misguided OVDP process. Sadly, it is so myopic that even the TAS Optometrist, Nina Olson, may not be able to mill a corrective lens for their broken glasses. So it goes.
you are in a very good position… you are probably completely forgoten by them anyway.. too many years, not a citizen. ect…. and you don’t live here anymore… are you sure you even need to do all this for just having a green card so many years ago? are green card (ex holders) need to pay taxes for life?
I think i’m going in the program, i don’t know if i should do it because i know it’s going to finish all my family and my hard work money.. I’m so sad and helpless now….
I did not exit the system properly (according to them) so technically I am still on their hook. My husband and I filed 1040s jointly (my income was being reported from our joint accounts so it only seemed fair to take the married deductions). However, I never filed FBARs (he did though) because I thought that FBARs were for US citizens and I had assumed wrongly (according to them) that I was a non-resident alien instead of a non-resident resident alien (or whatever they call it). I am definitely not off their radar because of the 1040s we filed together. Please ask more questions here and elsewhere before you consider OVDI. Wish I could be of more help.
I just got the impression that anything else is a huge risk, although i didn’t really understand the difference between what u r exposed to in a regular VD compared to opting out from OVDI.
Your situation is weird indeed… Sounds like a complete reasonable cause, taking in consideration that your spous sent the fbars…
Pingback: The Isaac Brock Society
“As you may know, I have often lamented the loss of LCUs (life credit units) that get devoted to all this unnecessary crap which is a total waste of human endeavor and time.”
Despite all the years that have passed, you might be glad to know that the worth of your LCUs can be officially calculated now: