READERS WHO LIVE IN BRITISH COLUMBIA, PLEASE TAKE NOTE OF THIS.This piece of information is contributed through a person wishing to maintain one-remove anonymity (no direct posting to Brock). I have received this information third-hand, but from a source I consider very reliable. (So this is at least two-remove posting. I haven’t personally spoken with the individual reporting this conversation with a Vancouver consulate official or employee.In a telephone conversation with the Vancouver consulate in August 2012, a person at the consulate said that there is deliberate “batching” in the processing of renunciations. When the current batch is completed, priority will be given to other – presumably deferred – tasks for an unspecified period of time. (This perspective may help to explain the recent considerable lengthening of wait for first appointment in Vancouver.)My advice to anyone in BC is, if it’s at all feasible and you want to get a CLN, go to Calgary or maybe Toronto, not Vancouver. They aren’t doing this, as far as we know, and certainly the appointment timings and CLN release information, starkly contrasted with what is going on in Vancouver, supports that assumption.The information isn’t clear on whether this batching occurs with relinquishments as well as renunciations, but as Vancouver (unlike the rest of the planet except the Ottawa embassy) doesn’t seem to make any procedural distinctions in terms of processing the two very different forms of CLN, I suspect they probably also are batching relinquishments.So, I would assume that if you go to Vancouver consulate, your application for either type of CLN could sit in a black hole for a rather long time. Bear that in mind when planning your course of action. I believe if you’ve already made a first appointment or even have had that first meeting, you can still proceed with your process at another consulate, but I don’t know whether that might adversely affect processing in Washington. It shouldn’t, and I do know one person who got the application switched from the embassy to a consulate, but that person hasn’t received the CLN yet so we don’t know for certain that it has no adverse consequences.
Long awaited article
Do Lucien Bouchard’s kids file their FBAR’s and US Tax Returns?
One thing that continually shocks me is just how many people are effected by the US’ Citizenship Based Taxation of all political stripes Doug Ford, David Alward, Elizabeth May, former Toronto Mayor David Miller, and now the children of long time and prominent Quebec Seperatist leader and founder of the Bloc Quebecois Lucien Bouchard. Here is wikipedia:
Bouchard separated from his second wife[8][9], Audrey Best (1960–2011), a Côte d’Azur-born California-reared airline stewardess, who later became a lawyer, whom he met on an international flight.[10] She was the daughter of James Best, a U.S. Navy officer, and his French wife, Marie-Josée Massay.
Bouchard is the father of two sons with Best, Alexandre and Simon, who hold dual Canadian-United States citizenship. Best held dual United States-France citizenship. She died on January 25, 2011, aged 50, from breast cancer.
I am curious what Bouchard thinks about current Bloc Quebecois leader Danielle Paille strong support of FATCA to root out “tax cheats” and other “scum.”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucien_Bouchard
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Paill%C3%A9
Other Canadians can probably describe to our non Canadian readers who Lucien Bouchard was. Sometimes something called Meech Lake is mentioned here all I will say is Bouchard was an a key player in it.
What do you think of America? Toronto National Post seeks your views
Can somebody repost this at the MapleSandbox.ca blog?
Anti-Americanism in the Arab world has increased to levels greater than in Bush era. A bitter outcome for Obama.” http://t.co/depJjkXG
— U.S. Citizen Abroad (@USCitizenAbroad) October 4, 2012
The most reasonable, vocal, articulate, justified and marketable – “Anti-Americanism” comes from U.S. citizens abroad http://t.co/6Al1Z77U
— U.S. Citizen Abroad (@USCitizenAbroad) June 16, 2012
USXCanada wrote an interesting post titled: Anti-Americanism in Canada.
So, my point is this:
On Thursday October 5, 2012 the following appeared on page A15 of the National Post:
What do you think of America?
Anti-U.S. sentiment is raging in some Muslim countries, but has take an more subtle tone in the past, even here in Canada.
Give your view in 75 words or fewer at letters@nationalpost.com
Watch for replies on October 9.
Please note that all letters must include your name, address and phone number (and this means your real name, address and phone number. General guidelines for letters to the editor are here:
Here is what I suggest.
1. It would be good to get a number of these off to the National Post; but in addition
2. Why not post 75 word letters as comments here.
The Isaac Brock Society (Petros under his real name) can then send a letter to the National Post that will reference this post and the comments. This may be a way to raise awareness on some of these issues. You might find the following article that appeared in the 2009 National Post to be of interest.
A 2009 article by Graeme Hamilton titled: Can Obama end our anti-Americansism?
General National Post articles on Anti-Americanism are here.
It seems to me that Anti-Americanism is at a fever pitch. It is NOT better under Obama. Now, US citizens abroad have become extremely articulate sources of anti-Americanism. Hardly surprising, given the abuse of US citizens abroad and FATCA. That said, FATCA is an attack on the sovereignty of Canada. This is an issue that should be of interest to all Canadians.
Just a thought, as @Tiger notes, we must find ways to get the story into media. FATCA hurts all Canadians and all freedom loving people everywhere.
To be clear, this should not be a bunch of general anti-Americanism (there is enough of that in other parts of the world). It should focus on the aspects of FATCA and citizenship-based taxation that affect Canada as a whole. Quite, obviously the issue is with the government and not with “amber waves of grain”.
Why US citizens in Canada should NOT invest in TFSAs or any other “Foreign Trust” (RRSPs excepted)
Crossposted from RenounceUScitizenship
Introduction – The Four Principles Of US Taxation Abroad
The U.S. tax system (at least in relation to U.S. citizens abroad) operates on the following four basic principles:
1. If something is “foreign” it should be punished.
2. The “principle of penalty” – There is no way that somebody can clean up innocent mistakes without paying penalties or the threat of penalties.
3. “No good deed goes unpunished” – Those who have filed (and are in the system) will have greater problems than those who have never filed. (Look at the new Streamlined compliance procedures for US citizens abroad for evidence of this – those who have filed cannot use the procedure to amend returns)
4. U.S. citizens abroad are tax cheats.
Those four principles sum it up.
Anita Greil, Managing Editor of the Wall Street Journal, is preparing an article on the effects of FATCA
ACA posted this on this on Facebook today: ‘She is looking for Americans who have encountered banking and financial issues/problems (account closures, refusals of service, etc.) as a result of FATCA for an upcoming article. If you would like to participate please get in touch with Anita at:
Anita.Greil@dowjones.com
phone: 41 43 443 8044
cell: 41 79 649 2039′
New Greenback Survey Reveals US Expat Government Dissatisfaction
Survey results show that the majority of American expat polled do not feel fairly represented by the US Government. Implications of the dissatisfaction may play a role in the upcoming elections as an estimated 6 million US citizens currently living overseas cast their votes in the hopes of having their concerns and needs addressed.
For years, we’ve been hearing from our customers a mounting swell of frustration and dissatisfaction with the government as it relates to addressing their concerns, particularly when it comes to their expat tax preparation.
New York, NY (PRWEB) October 04, 2012
New survey results show that more than 72% of U.S. expatriates polled do not feel fairly represented by the U.S. Government. The survey also found that, of those polled, 74% were either prepared or planning to vote. Conducted by Greenback Expat Tax Services, which specializes exclusively on American expat tax services, the results represent a growing dissatisfaction among Americans living overseas with the lack of support and attention paid to their unique needs.
“We’re not surprised by our survey’s results,” said David McKeegan, Greenback Expat Tax Services President. For years, we’ve been hearing from our customers a mounting swell of frustration and dissatisfaction with the government as it relates to addressing their concerns, particularly when it comes to their expat tax preparation.”…
Getting FATCA covered on The Agenda with Steve Paikin on TVO(TV Ontario)
Hi, everyone I have been continuing to think about different ways to get this issued covered in the Canadian media. One outlet I keep on coming across is trying to get Steve Paikin on TVO to do a show on FATCA and US Citizenship based taxation in Canada. Paikin’s show tends to cover a lot of issues that don’t get covered anywhere else in the Canadian or US media and is willing to cover issues effected either Canada or the US or both. My thoughts on prospective guests which I might suggest to the producers include Phil Hodgen, Jackie Bugnion, Marylouise Serrato from the “US” and from Canada “Blaze” of Maple Sandbox fame who has a TV background, Arthur Cockfield, someone from the CBA either Maura Drew-Lytle or Darren Hannah, and possibly either a Conservative or NDP MP(Craig Scott, Denise Savoie, Megan Leslie etc). At this time for personal reasons I cannot appear if it ever got to that point although I have to say it would be a dream come true for me to make a TV appearance.
Here is the link to the staff of the show. If any Brockers have a connection to any of these people let me know.
http://theagenda.tvo.org/about
If I don’t hear anything in a couple of days I am going to make my own approach to the producers and hopefully others can reach out and vouch for what I tell them. Additionally suggestions on guests are welcome. I want to give them a good list of people they can reach out and contact who are willing to go on TV.
US Citizenship: The “Negative Marketing Option” Trap
AnonAnon posted this comment on the Consulate Report Directory thread, sharing their thoughts on how the US could clear up the problems of unwanted dual citizenship. It’s an important topic, one worthy of a thread of its own.
Amb Jacobson: Most important thing US can do for Canada is improve economy of US
The single most important thing the United States can do for Canada is improve its ailing economy, says the U.S. ambassador to Canada.
Envoy David Jacobson says Wednesday’s first presidential debate will play in key role in determining whether President Barack Obama or his Republican challenger Mitt Romney get to tackle that job next year.
I have often said that the single most important thing the United States can do for Canada is to get our economy back on track,” he added.
“If we get our economy back on track, it has enormous positive implications for Canada.”
Jacobson emphasized he was speaking as the U.S. ambassador to all Americans, even though he is a Democrat who was part of Obama’s historic 2008 election team. He was the chief of Obama’s appointments office for the first nine months of 2009 before he took up his post in Ottawa, three years ago this week.

